Florida Law·Florida

Emergency Board Meetings in Florida: When They Are Allowed and How to Call One | CIC-SC

CIC-SC Editorial Team··~25 minutes read

Florida Law · Meetings & Procedure

Emergency Board Meetings in Florida: When They Are Allowed and How to Call One

Florida community-association law contains two distinct emergency frameworks: the routine emergency-meeting exception to the 48-hour notice rule, and the broader emergency powers that activate when the Governor declares a state of emergency. Most boards conflate them. The two have different triggers, different scopes, and different procedural rules — and only one of them lets a Florida board contract on behalf of unit owners. Here is how each works and when each applies.

By the CIC-SC Editorial Team Updated May 12, 2026 Reading time: ~11 minutes Audience: Florida Boards, Officers, Managers, Counsel

Why Florida Has Two Emergency Frameworks

The Florida Legislature treats “emergency” differently depending on the scale and nature of the situation. The first framework lives inside the open-meetings statute. It addresses the everyday-emergency case: a burst pipe, an expiring insurance binder, a vendor that disappeared mid-project — the kind of event that demands board action within hours, not days, but that does not require any state-level declaration. The second framework is reserved for catastrophic events: hurricanes, public-health emergencies, civil disturbances, situations that require the Governor of Florida to declare a state of emergency under Chapter 252 of the Florida Statutes. Each framework grants different powers and imposes different procedural disciplines.

Confusing the two is the most common Florida emergency-meeting mistake. A board that purports to exercise § 718.1265 or § 720.316 emergency powers without an active gubernatorial declaration is not exercising those powers at all — it is taking ordinary board action under the wrong label. Conversely, a board operating during a true declared emergency that limits itself to ordinary 48-hour-notice procedures may forfeit the broader authority the Legislature has provided for that situation. The two are independent. Boards should know both.

An emergency under the 48-hour-notice exception is a tactical accommodation. Emergency powers under a declared state of emergency are a separate legal regime. They are not the same thing.

Framework One: The Routine Emergency-Meeting Exception

The default rule for both condominium and homeowners’ association board meetings is that notice must be posted in a conspicuous place at least 48 continuous hours before the meeting and must specifically identify the agenda items. Beyond posting, condominium associations have additional notice obligations under § 718.112(2)(c); HOAs have different alternatives under § 720.303(2). Both statutes carve out an exception for emergencies.

Condominium Associations — Fla. Stat. § 718.112(2)(c)

Section 718.112(2)(c) requires that adequate notice of all condominium board meetings, identifying the agenda, be posted conspicuously on the condominium property at least 48 continuous hours before the meeting — except in an emergency. Florida law then layers on a specific procedural protection for items not included on the meeting notice:

  • An item not included on the notice may be taken up on an emergency basis by a vote of at least a majority plus one of the board members; and
  • Such emergency action must be noticed and ratified at the next regular board meeting.

The majority-plus-one threshold is meaningful. On a five-director board, a simple majority is three; the emergency threshold is four. On a seven-director board, the majority-plus-one threshold is five (rather than the simple-majority four). The Legislature elevated the vote requirement because the action is being taken outside the ordinary notice-and-agenda discipline; the higher threshold is intended to ensure a strong board consensus when members were not on notice of the item.

If the emergency meeting is being held by video conference under Florida law, the notice (where notice is given) must state that the meeting will be by video conference and must include a hyperlink and a conference telephone number for unit owners to attend remotely, as well as the address of the physical location where unit owners can attend in person. These video-conference notice requirements apply to ordinary board meetings; in a true emergency, the practical question is whether the format permits owners to observe to the extent feasible and whether the post-meeting ratification process restores transparency.

Homeowners’ Associations — Fla. Stat. § 720.303(2)

For HOAs, Section 720.303(2) provides that notice of all board meetings must specifically identify the agenda items and must be posted in a conspicuous place in the community at least 48 hours in advance — except in an emergency. In the alternative, an HOA may mail or deliver notice to each member at least seven days before the meeting, except in an emergency. For HOAs with more than 100 members, the bylaws may provide for reasonable alternatives to posting or mailing, including publication, a posted schedule of meetings, or repeated broadcasting on a closed-circuit cable system serving the community.

The Chapter 720 framework does not contain the same explicit majority-plus-one language for emergency items that appears in Chapter 718. HOA boards exercising the emergency exception should default to a higher consensus threshold (a majority of the full board, not just a quorum) and should document the emergency basis carefully, both because of the ratification expectation in practice and because a thinly supported emergency action invites later challenge. Where the HOA’s governing documents impose a stricter vote requirement for the action being taken, that document-level requirement controls.

What Qualifies as an Emergency

Neither § 718.112(2)(c) nor § 720.303(2) defines “emergency” with statutory precision. Florida practitioners and the DBPR have consistently treated the term as referring to a situation that arises with insufficient time for the standard 48-hour notice, that requires substantive board action, and that cannot reasonably be addressed by the manager within the manager’s contractual authority or by the existing emergency powers in the association’s contracts and insurance. Examples that consistently qualify:

  • Catastrophic property damage requiring immediate authorization of remediation costs above the manager’s spending authority.
  • Vendor failure or walk-off where immediate replacement or release is necessary to prevent material harm.
  • Insurance carrier deadlines that fall before the next regularly noticed meeting and that require a board-level decision.
  • A regulatory or court-ordered deadline that cannot be moved and requires the association’s execution.
  • An imminent health-and-safety situation (building-system failure, security breach, contamination, etc.).
What does not qualify. A foreseeable matter the board chose not to schedule. A vote the board prefers to take quickly. A vendor selection on a board-self-imposed timeline. Routine business that simply slipped off the agenda. The emergency exception is not a tool for board convenience; it is a tool for situations that cannot accommodate the standard notice cycle.

The Ratification Obligation

Section 718.112(2)(c) is explicit that emergency action taken on an item not in the notice must be noticed and ratified at the next regular board meeting. The ratification is not a formality. It is the mechanism the Legislature uses to restore the transparency that the no-notice action temporarily suspended. The next-meeting agenda should include the ratification item by name; the discussion should occur in open session; the vote should be recorded in the minutes; and members should have a meaningful opportunity to ask questions about the underlying emergency and the action taken.

For HOAs under Chapter 720, the statute does not impose the same explicit ratification language, but the better practice is the same: notice the ratification item on the next regular meeting agenda, summarize the emergency action in open session, and capture the summary and ratification vote in the minutes. The transparency value is identical; the procedural defensibility is meaningfully higher.

Framework Two: Emergency Powers During a Declared State of Emergency

Sections 718.1265 (condominium associations) and 720.316 (homeowners’ associations) provide a separate, much broader emergency authority. These provisions activate when there is a declared state of emergency — typically a gubernatorial declaration under Chapter 252 of the Florida Statutes — in the locality where the property is located. The DBPR has clarified that these emergency powers are available to both condominium and homeowners’ associations when the underlying declaration is in effect.

What the Statutes Authorize

The emergency-powers provisions allow association boards to take a wide range of actions in response to damage or injury caused by, or reasonably anticipated in connection with, the declared emergency. The authorizations typically include:

  • Conducting board meetings, committee meetings, elections, and membership meetings, in whole or in part, by telephone, real-time video conference, or similar real-time communication, with notice given as is practicable.
  • Designating assistant officers who are not directors and giving them authority to act when officers are unavailable.
  • Relocating the association’s principal office or designating alternative principal offices.
  • Implementing disaster plans before, during, or after an emergency event, including shutting down or off elevators, electricity, water, sewer, or security systems.
  • Determining, in the board’s sole discretion (and with appropriate consultation with licensed professionals), portions of the property unsafe or unavailable for entry or occupancy.
  • Requiring evacuation in the case of a condominium (an authority the HOA statute does not grant).
  • Contracting, on behalf of unit owners (for condominiums only), for items or services for which owners are otherwise individually responsible but that are necessary to prevent further injury, contagion, or damage.
  • Levying special assessments or borrowing money without member approval where otherwise required, when reasonably necessary to address the emergency.
  • Modifying the use of association property to address the emergency.

Key Differences Between Condo and HOA Emergency Powers

The two emergency-power statutes are parallel but not identical. Two differences matter most in practice:

PowerCondominium (§ 718.1265)HOA (§ 720.316)
Require evacuation of the propertyYesNo
Contract on behalf of owners for items they are otherwise individually responsible forYesNo
Conduct remote meetings with practicable noticeYesYes
Implement disaster plans, modify use, levy emergency assessmentsYesYes
Designate parts of the property unsafe or unavailableYesYes

Limits and Conditions

The emergency-powers statutes are powerful but not unlimited. Several conditions and limits apply:

  • A state of emergency must be in effect. The authority is triggered by declaration and ends when the declaration expires or is terminated. Acting under the emergency-powers framework outside an active declaration is acting under no authority at all.
  • The action must respond to the emergency. The board cannot use a hurricane declaration to take routine action unrelated to the storm and its aftermath. The connection must be reasonable.
  • The action must be consistent with the declaration’s scope. Local declarations bind only their geography; statewide declarations apply statewide. A property under a county-only declaration cannot invoke emergency-power authority unrelated to that county’s emergency.
  • Documentation still matters. Decisions made under emergency powers should be reduced to writing, dated, and made part of the official records. The emergency-powers framework does not waive the official-records obligations under Chapter 718 or 720.
  • The board’s fiduciary duty does not change. Directors acting under emergency powers remain subject to the standard of conduct in § 617.0830. A defensive use of emergency powers is protected by the business judgment rule; an abusive use is not.
Common pitfall. Boards sometimes “reach for” emergency powers because the situation feels serious enough to justify them, even when no state of emergency is in effect. The reach is legally empty. If the Governor has not declared a state of emergency that applies to the property, §§ 718.1265 and 720.316 are dormant. The board may still have the ordinary emergency-meeting exception under §§ 718.112(2)(c) or 720.303(2), but the broader powers are not available.

How to Tell Which Framework Applies

Use this short diagnostic before invoking any emergency authority:

  1. Is there an active state of emergency declared by the Governor (or applicable local executive) covering the property? If yes, §§ 718.1265 (condo) or 720.316 (HOA) may apply alongside the ordinary 48-hour-notice exception. If no, the emergency-powers framework is not available; only the ordinary exception is.
  2. Is the action being contemplated related to the declared emergency? If yes, the board may exercise emergency powers. If no, the board is operating under ordinary rules even if a declaration is in effect.
  3. Can the matter wait 48 hours for properly noticed action? If yes, post a proper notice; do not use any emergency framework. If no, use the ordinary emergency exception (and the emergency-powers framework if both conditions above are met).
  4. For condos: does the board have at least a majority plus one prepared to act? If no, the § 718.112(2)(c) emergency-item authority cannot be exercised on items not in the notice.
  5. For all associations: is the next regular meeting prepared to ratify (and notice the ratification of) the emergency action? If no, build that step into the immediate post-emergency workflow.

Practical Scenarios

Scenario 1: Pipe Burst in a Common Element (No Declared Emergency)

A condominium experiences a major water-line break in a common-element corridor on a Sunday morning. Remediation must begin immediately; estimated cost is $58,000. The board convenes a video meeting Sunday afternoon. The item is not on any prior notice. Four of five directors approve the remediation scope and the related insurance posture (majority plus one). At the next regular board meeting, the agenda includes a noticed ratification item; the board summarizes the action in open session and votes to ratify. Result: proper § 718.112(2)(c) emergency-item handling, with the higher vote threshold met and ratification properly noticed.

Scenario 2: Hurricane With Active Declaration

The Governor declares a state of emergency covering the property’s county 48 hours before a hurricane is expected to make landfall. The condominium board, citing § 718.1265, convenes a remote meeting with practicable notice, authorizes evacuation of the building, contracts on behalf of unit owners for board-up and storm-prep services, and levies an emergency special assessment to cover deductibles and immediate response costs. The actions are reduced to written resolutions, dated, and made part of the official records. Result: proper § 718.1265 emergency-powers use; the declaration is in effect; the actions respond to the emergency; documentation is in place.

Scenario 3: HOA Tries to Contract for an Owner’s Roof Repair

The same hurricane hits an HOA community. The board attempts to contract on behalf of homeowners for individual roof repairs, citing § 720.316. Analysis: Section 720.316 does not grant HOAs the power to contract on behalf of owners for items the owners are individually responsible for. That power exists only under § 718.1265 for condominium associations. The HOA can communicate with vendors, recommend contractors, and coordinate community-wide repair, but it cannot bind individual owners. The proper path is a community-level recovery plan that respects each homeowner’s contracting authority.

Scenario 4: A Board Reaches for Emergency Powers Without a Declaration

An HOA board, frustrated by an obstreperous vendor, declares a “board emergency” and purports to invoke § 720.316 to terminate the contract and engage a replacement. No state of emergency is in effect. Analysis: Section 720.316 is not available; the “board emergency” label is meaningless. The action must be taken under ordinary board authority, with either a properly noticed special meeting or the § 720.303(2) emergency-meeting exception if the timing truly cannot accommodate notice. Using the emergency-powers framework outside a declared emergency is procedurally vulnerable and may expose directors personally.

Scenario 5: Condo Insurance Renewal Pressure

The condominium’s wind insurer issues a binding renewal quote that expires in 36 hours; the renewal includes new coinsurance language requiring board approval. The board convenes a Subsection 718.112(2)(c) emergency meeting by video, four of five directors vote to accept the renewal, and the action is properly ratified at the next regular meeting. Result: appropriate use of the emergency-meeting exception — not because the carrier’s schedule creates a statutory emergency in the abstract, but because the practical timing (less than 48 hours) genuinely does not accommodate ordinary notice and the substance materially affects the association’s coverage.

Common Mistakes Florida Boards Make

Confusing the Two Frameworks

The single most common error is treating “emergency” as one concept rather than two distinct legal regimes. The 48-hour-notice exception and the § 718.1265 / 720.316 emergency powers are independent. A board can use the first without the second; using the second requires the first plus a triggering declaration. Boards that conflate the two either overreach (claiming powers they do not have) or underreach (failing to exercise powers they do have during a genuine declared event).

Skipping the Ratification at the Next Regular Meeting

For condominium emergency actions on items not in the notice, § 718.112(2)(c) requires ratification at the next regular board meeting. Boards routinely take the emergency action and treat the matter as closed, without including ratification on the next agenda. This is a procedural defect that an unhappy owner can later cite to challenge the underlying decision.

Missing the Majority-Plus-One Threshold

For condos, the emergency-item vote threshold is majority plus one of the entire board — not a simple majority of the directors present. A five-member board needs four affirmative votes; a seven-member board needs five. Boards that calculate the threshold from those present at the meeting (rather than the whole board) frequently fall short and produce a procedurally invalid action.

Failing to Document the Emergency Basis

Whether the board is operating under the 48-hour-notice exception, § 718.1265 / 720.316 emergency powers, or both, the official records should reflect the factual basis for the emergency designation. A two-sentence narrative in the minutes — the situation, the timing constraint, the necessity for board action — is the difference between a defensible decision and a contestable one.

Treating Manager Authority as Board Authority

A community-association manager often has contractual authority to respond to emergencies up to a spending cap. The manager’s action is not the same as a board decision and does not require an emergency board meeting. If the situation exceeds the manager’s authority, the board must convene; if it does not, the board need not.

Building a Reliable Florida Emergency-Meeting Practice

  1. Adopt an emergency-meeting policy that references both frameworks. The policy should distinguish ordinary 48-hour-notice emergencies from declared-emergency events and explain the procedural steps for each.
  2. Maintain a current call tree. Directors’ current phone, email, and back-up contact information should be in the manager’s records, the secretary’s records, and the president’s records.
  3. Maintain a current vendor list with after-hours contacts. Emergency plumber, electrician, roofer, water-mitigation, structural engineer, general counsel, and insurance broker contacts should be reviewed quarterly.
  4. Pre-approve a disaster plan. Florida law expressly authorizes implementation of pre-existing disaster plans during a declared emergency. Boards that adopt and update a plan in advance have a procedural head start.
  5. Default to special meetings whenever 48 hours of notice is feasible. A properly noticed special meeting is procedurally bulletproof. Reserve the emergency exception for situations the 48-hour timeline cannot accommodate.
  6. Add a standing “Ratification of Emergency Actions” agenda item. Most regular meetings will have nothing under it; the ones that do will be properly documented.
  7. Confirm authority with counsel for high-stakes emergency decisions. A five-minute call with association counsel before the emergency meeting can be the difference between a defensible action and a contested one — especially during a declared emergency, where the scope of authority is broader and the temptation to overreach is greater.

Frequently Asked Questions

Does the Florida Statute § 718.112(2)(c) emergency exception apply only to items not on the notice, or to the whole meeting?
The 48-hour-notice exception applies to the meeting itself when an emergency genuinely prevents ordinary notice. The separate majority-plus-one rule applies to items taken up at a meeting that were not on the notice (whether or not the underlying meeting was an “emergency” meeting). The two work together: emergency meetings frequently involve items the board could not put on a notice in advance, so the majority-plus-one vote and the next-meeting ratification typically apply.
Can an HOA exercise the emergency exception in § 720.303(2) without invoking § 720.316?
Yes. The two are independent. § 720.303(2) addresses the everyday-emergency case where 48-hour notice is impracticable. § 720.316 addresses the declared-emergency case and is dormant unless a triggering declaration is in effect. HOAs use the first regularly; they use the second only when a state of emergency has been declared.
Are video-conference meetings permitted during emergency action?
Yes. Florida law generally permits board meetings to be conducted by video conference with appropriate notice elements (hyperlink, conference number, physical location). During a declared emergency under § 718.1265 or § 720.316, the authority is even broader: real-time remote meetings with practicable notice. Most boards default to video conference for emergency situations and supplement with phone bridges for directors without video access.
Can the board levy a special assessment at an emergency meeting?
Under the ordinary 48-hour-notice exception, the board can take action within its existing authority — including special assessments if the declaration and bylaws permit board-authorized assessments. Under § 718.1265, condominium boards have expanded authority during a declared emergency to levy special assessments necessary to address the event. Under § 720.316, HOAs have similar (though slightly narrower) authority. Where the governing documents require a membership vote for the assessment, the emergency authority does not bypass that requirement absent express statutory override.
What is the ratification requirement, and when does the deadline run?
For condominium boards under § 718.112(2)(c), emergency actions on items not in the notice must be noticed and ratified at the next regular board meeting. That meeting’s agenda must include the ratification by name, the action must be summarized in open session, and the ratification vote must be recorded. The same discipline is best practice for HOAs even though the statutory text differs.
Do emergency powers under §§ 718.1265 and 720.316 expire?
Yes. The emergency-powers authority is in effect only while the underlying state-of-emergency declaration is in effect. When the declaration expires or is terminated, the broader authority ends, although actions properly taken during the declared period remain valid. Ongoing implementation of disaster-plan elements may continue if they were properly authorized during the active period.
Can a single director declare an emergency unilaterally?
No. The decision to convene an emergency meeting is a board-level decision, typically initiated by the president or another officer with that authority in the bylaws. A single director cannot bind the association. Emergency powers under §§ 718.1265 and 720.316 are association-level authorities exercised by the board acting as a board.
What happens if an owner challenges the emergency designation later?
A reviewing forum — DBPR arbitration, a Florida court, or both depending on the matter — will look at whether the underlying facts honestly fit the emergency category, whether the procedural requirements were satisfied (majority-plus-one for condo emergency items, ratification, recordkeeping), and whether the action was within the board’s authority. Boards that document the basis, follow the procedure, and remain within their authority are well positioned. Boards that rely on the “emergency” label without the underlying substance are exposed.
Does Florida’s 2026 legislative session change any of this?
The 2026 Florida Regular Session did not enact significant amendments to the routine emergency-meeting provisions in §§ 718.112(2)(c) and 720.303(2) or to the declared-emergency provisions in §§ 718.1265 and 720.316. The substantive 2025 amendments (HB 913 and HB 1203) continue to operate alongside the emergency frameworks discussed here. Boards should review the CIC-SC 2026 Legislative Compliance Briefing for the broader picture.

Key Takeaways

  • Florida has two emergency frameworks: the routine 48-hour-notice exception in §§ 718.112(2)(c) and 720.303(2), and the broader emergency powers under §§ 718.1265 and 720.316 that activate when a state of emergency has been declared.
  • For condominium boards, an item not in the meeting notice may be taken up on emergency basis by a vote of majority plus one of the board (not a simple majority), and the emergency action must be noticed and ratified at the next regular board meeting.
  • For HOAs, § 720.303(2) carves out an emergency exception to the 48-hour posting or seven-day mailing requirement but does not impose the same explicit majority-plus-one threshold; best practice is to document the emergency basis and to ratify at the next regular meeting.
  • Emergency powers under §§ 718.1265 and 720.316 require an active state-of-emergency declaration. Without the trigger, the broader powers are dormant.
  • Condominiums have two emergency-power authorities that HOAs do not: the power to require evacuation and the power to contract on behalf of owners for items the owners are otherwise individually responsible for.
  • The fiduciary duty in § 617.0830 and the business-judgment-rule protection it implies travel with the directors into the emergency. Documentation supports the protection; missing documentation undermines it.
  • The most common Florida emergency-meeting error is conflating the two frameworks — either reaching for § 718.1265 or § 720.316 without a triggering declaration, or failing to invoke them when a declaration is in effect and the broader authority is needed.
  • A clean Florida emergency-meeting practice rests on a written policy, current call trees and vendor lists, a pre-approved disaster plan, a default to special meetings whenever 48 hours of notice is feasible, and a standing ratification agenda item.
Operate Florida’s emergency-meeting frameworks the way the statutes read.
The CIC-SC Florida Insights series includes emergency-meeting policy templates compliant with §§ 718.112(2)(c) and 720.303(2), pre-declared-emergency disaster plans aligned with §§ 718.1265 and 720.316, ratification language, and the documentation patterns that hold up to DBPR review and unit-owner challenge. Become a CIC-SC member to access the full library.

References & Sources

  1. Fla. Stat. § 718.112 — Bylaws of Condominium Associations (including (2)(c) meeting and emergency-item provisions).
  2. Fla. Stat. § 718.1265 — Association Emergency Powers (condominiums).
  3. Fla. Stat. § 718.111 — The Association (powers, duties, and official records).
  4. Fla. Stat. § 720.303 — Association Powers and Duties; Meetings of Board; Official Records; Budgets; Financial Reporting.
  5. Fla. Stat. § 720.316 — Association Emergency Powers (homeowners’ associations).
  6. Fla. Stat. § 617.0830 — General Standards for Directors (corporations not for profit).
  7. Fla. Stat. Chapter 252 — Emergency Management (state-of-emergency declarations).
  8. Florida HB 913 (2024) — Condominium and Cooperative Associations amendments.
  9. Florida HB 1021 (2024) — Condominium Associations amendments.
  10. Florida HB 1203 (2024) — Homeowners’ Associations amendments.
  11. Florida Department of Business and Professional Regulation (DBPR), Division of Florida Condominiums, Timeshares, and Mobile Homes — published guidance on emergency powers and meeting procedure.
  12. Common Interest Community Standards Council, Fundamentals of Association Management — chapter on Meeting Compliance and Emergency Operations.

Related Resources & Additional Reading from the CIC-SC Library

  • Florida Chapter 718 — Condominium Act Overview for Board Members
  • Virtual and Electronic Board Meetings in Florida
  • Florida Director Conflict of Interest — §§ 718.3027 and 720.3033 Explained
  • Florida Condominium Board Election Process Under § 718.112(2)(d)
  • HOA Records Retention Policy: Florida Under § 718.111(12) and § 720.303(5)
  • Florida SIRS — Structural Integrity Reserve Study Compliance Timeline
  • Florida Condo Milestone Inspection Requirements — Compliance Guide
  • Compliance Before Conflict — A Modern Approach to HOA Deed Restriction Enforcement

Tags: Florida emergency board meeting · § 718.112(2)(c) · § 720.303(2) · § 718.1265 · § 720.316 · declared state of emergency · majority plus one · ratification · condominium emergency · HOA emergency powers · Florida governance

Disclaimer. This article is published by the Common Interest Community Standards Council for educational and informational purposes only. It is not legal advice and does not establish an attorney-client relationship. Statutory references are intended to support informed governance, not to substitute for advice from qualified Florida legal counsel. The distinction between the ordinary emergency-meeting exception and the declared-emergency powers, the application of the majority-plus-one threshold for condominium boards, and the scope of emergency authority under §§ 718.1265 and 720.316 depend on specific facts and the current state of Florida law. Boards should consult counsel when meaningful legal exposure may be involved and should monitor DBPR guidance and gubernatorial declarations during active emergencies. CIC-SC, its authors, and its members assume no liability for actions taken in reliance on this content.

Notice: CICSC provides educational resources, governance standards, and practical advisory support. CICSC does not provide legal advice, accounting advice, tax advice, engineering advice, insurance advice, or reserve study services. Board members and associations should consult qualified professionals for matters requiring professional judgment or legal interpretation.